Trump Judge Appointments Face Republican Resistance in Lame-Duck Senate Blitz

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump is running out of time to reshape the federal courts, and the resistance is now coming from inside his own party. A last-minute effort to install as many judges as possible before Democrats take control of the United States Senate is running into opposition from a handful of fellow Republicans, according to a Reuters report published on Sunday, November 15, 2026.

Until recently, the confirmations had moved almost without friction. Senate Republicans had routinely approved Trump’s nominees for lifetime seats on district and appeals courts during his second term, confirming 57 so far and helping him cement a conservative imprint on the judiciary that will outlast his presidency. But as the White House and Senate Republican leaders press ahead with judicial nominees during the lame-duck session, a handful of Republicans have blocked or cast doubt on three nominees selected for their home states.

US Capitol dome in Washington
US Capitol dome, Washington. Photo: Ivan Dražić

The three nominees in trouble

The clearest sign of trouble came on Tuesday, when the White House took the rare step of withdrawing one nomination and replacing it with another. US District Judge Lee Rudofsky had been nominated to the St. Louis-based 8th US Circuit Court of Appeals. After US Senators John Boozman and Tom Cotton of Arkansas opposed Rudofsky, the White House pulled his name and replaced him with Arkansas Supreme Court Justice J. Cody Hiland.

A second fight is unfolding in Oklahoma. Outgoing Republican Senator Alan Armstrong has withheld public support for Zach West, a lawyer nominated for a federal judgeship in the state. Supporting Armstrong in his opposition is North Carolina Senator Thom Tillis, who serves on the Senate Judiciary Committee. Plans for the committee to vote on Tuesday on two nominees to Oklahoma’s federal court were derailed by the opposition West faces, according to a source familiar with the nominations process.

A third nominee is in limbo in Texas. Senator John Cornyn has declined to commit to supporting T. Elliot Gaiser, Trump’s nominee for a federal judgeship in Dallas. Gaiser now leads the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel, which has issued opinions endorsing some of the most controversial elements of Trump’s agenda. Without a blue slip from Cornyn, Gaiser cannot appear at a Judiciary Committee hearing scheduled for Wednesday.

The blue slip: why home-state senators still matter

To understand why three objections can stall a presidential blitz, it helps to understand the Senate’s oldest unwritten rule on judges. Senators traditionally help choose judges for vacancies in their states. Trial court nominees are especially vulnerable because, under Senate custom, home-state senators can block them by withholding a “blue slip,” a form indicating support to the Senate Judiciary Committee.

The blue slip is not a law. It is a tradition, and its strength has varied over the years depending on who chairs the Judiciary Committee. But in practice, a withheld blue slip has often been enough to stop a district court nomination, because committee chairs have been reluctant to advance a nominee over the objection of a home-state senator from the president’s own party.

Tillis is retiring. Cornyn lost a primary to a Trump-backed challenger. Both men are now in their final days in office, and both have indicated a willingness to block some nominees pending before the Senate Judiciary Committee, of which they are both members. Armstrong will leave the Senate on November 30 and be replaced by Senator-elect Kevin Hern, a Republican who could take a different position on West.

Thune and Grassley race the clock

Senate Majority Leader John Thune said on Monday that judicial confirmations were a top priority while Republicans retain control of the chamber. “The priority is going to be getting the judges across the finish line,” Thune told reporters, according to CBS News.

Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley of Iowa has laid the groundwork for a sprint. In an article in the Wall Street Journal on November 10, Grassley wrote that Senate Republicans can safeguard the nation’s founding principles for generations by confirming Trump’s remaining judicial nominees to lifetime appointments. He said the committee had moved judicial confirmations at the fastest pace since the Reagan administration, and he has scheduled two hearings within an eight-day span this month — a break from the panel’s typical practice of holding such hearings once every two weeks.

The committee’s aggressive calendar has already produced results. It voted to advance four of the president’s district court candidates and held confirmation hearings for four other judicial nominees on Tuesday. Wyoming Senator John Barrasso, the Republican whip, summed up the mood: “We’re going to make every second count, and that means all these judicial appointments.”

US Supreme Court building in Washington
US Supreme Court building. Photo: Mark Stebnicki

Why the midterm election changed everything

None of this urgency existed a month ago. The reason is the midterm election of November 3, 2026, in which Democrats won control of both the House of Representatives and the Senate. The current Congress remains in office until the new one convenes in January 2027, but the balance of power has already shifted in practice.

Democrats are projected to hold at least 55 seats in the Senate, including independents who caucus with them, against 44 for Republicans, with Alaska alone uncalled, according to Associated Press calls reported on November 11 to 13. In Alaska, former Representative Mary Peltola, a Democrat, had widened her lead over Republican Senator Dan Sullivan in the latest count on Friday. In the House, Democrats are projected to hold at least 255 seats to 169 for Republicans, with 12 contests still undecided.

Once Democrats take over in January, that path closes. “No one, or nearly no one, is going to get confirmed, so what he does in terms of nominating people, we’ll see,” Ed Whelan, a distinguished senior fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center and a former law clerk to the late Justice Antonin Scalia, told CBS News.

The Texas angle: a new senator, a new veto

Texas illustrates how the midterm result has changed the politics of judicial nominations in real time. On November 4, Republican Senator Ted Cruz called a top lawyer in Trump’s Justice Department to solicit the lawyer’s interest in filling a seat in Texas, after the state elected James Talarico, a Democrat who will have veto power over district court nominees once he takes office. Trump formally announced the nomination of Gaiser less than a week later.

If Cornyn withholds his blue slip, Gaiser cannot get a hearing on Wednesday, no matter how quickly Grassley wants to move. And if Talarico takes office in January with a veto over future Texas district court nominees, the White House’s ability to fill Texas vacancies will shrink dramatically. Every vacancy that is not filled before January becomes a vacancy that Democrats can block, delay or trade away for the next two years.

What happens next

Three things are worth watching. First, the vote on Monday on Domenico’s nomination to the 10th Circuit — the first test of whether the Republican resistance is limited to a few home-state disputes or is spreading to appeals court nominees as well. Second, the Judiciary Committee hearing on Wednesday, and whether Gaiser appears before it. Third, the Oklahoma vote, which was derailed once already: if Armstrong and Tillis hold their ground, West’s nomination may never reach the Senate floor.

For now, the Trump judge appointments blitz is still moving — but it is no longer moving smoothly. The president who remade the federal judiciary in his first term, and added 57 more judges in his second, is discovering in the final weeks of Republican Senate control that the hardest opposition to overcome may come from senators in his own party, in their final days in office, with nothing left to lose.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many Trump judge appointments have been confirmed in his second term?

Fifty-seven judges have been confirmed so far in Trump’s second term, according to Reuters. That is in addition to the 234 judicial appointments he made during his first term from 2017 to 2021, including three Supreme Court justices. Roughly one-third of active federal judges are now Trump appointees.

What is a blue slip, and why does it matter?

A blue slip is a form the Senate Judiciary Committee sends to a nominee’s home-state senators to indicate their support. Under Senate custom, a home-state senator can block a trial court nominee by withholding it. In the current lame-duck session, Republican senators have used that power against three of Trump’s nominees.

What happens to the pending nominees if they are not confirmed by January?

Once Democrats take control of the Senate in January, they are expected to block or slow Trump’s remaining nominees. A White House official said it expects all 23 pending nominees to be confirmed this year, but any nominee left unconfirmed would have to be renominated and would face a Democratic-controlled Judiciary Committee.

Related coverage: Ukraine Donbas NATO membership swap and Canada US trade deal progress.

Leave a Comment