Sanders Refuses to Back Schumer in Senate Leadership Fight

Senator Bernie Sanders said on Tuesday that he will not support Chuck Schumer’s bid to remain the leader of Senate Democrats, delivering the most serious blow yet to Schumer’s effort to become majority leader when the new Congress takes office in January.

Sanders, the independent senator from Vermont who caucuses with Democrats, made the announcement at a news conference at the US Capitol alongside Senator Elissa Slotkin of Michigan, who also declined to back Schumer. The move turns a quiet revolt inside the Democratic caucus into an open fight over who should lead the party’s new Senate majority — and what that majority should stand for.

“I personally have known Chuck Schumer for over 30 years, and I like Chuck. Nobody works harder than Chuck Schumer,” Sanders told reporters. “But, in my view, the time is now for change, and I will not be supporting Chuck to be reelected as the Democratic leader.”

Schumer, who has led Senate Democrats since 2017, responded within hours, insisting he remains confident he will be elected majority leader. But the public break by Sanders leaves the New York senator facing the most serious leadership challenge of his career, just one week after Democrats won back the Senate in the November 3 midterm elections.

What Sanders said — and why now

Sanders framed his decision as a response to what voters said at the ballot box. The midterm campaign, he argued, was about change, and the voters who handed Democrats the Senate want a different direction from Washington, particularly as families struggle with the cost of housing, health care and everyday expenses. He also tied his stance to the fight over income and wealth inequality, the issue that has defined his political career.

Sanders and Slotkin had just come from a meeting with Schumer before they faced reporters, according to reports of the news conference. Schumer laid out some of his ideas for leading the new majority, but Sanders said they did not go far enough. He called instead for a vigorous debate about the future of the Democratic Party, and predicted Schumer would not go unchallenged. “He’s not going to run unopposed, I don’t think,” he said.

The US Capitol in Washington, DC
The US Capitol in Washington, DC, where Senate Democrats will choose their next leader by secret ballot. Photo by Ivan Dražić / Pexels

Slotkin: “a concrete plan that’s definitively different”

Slotkin’s refusal to back Schumer may matter as much as Sanders’ own. She is a first-term senator from a battleground state who won her seat in 2024, the same year Donald Trump carried Michigan in the presidential race. She served in the House from 2019, worked as a CIA analyst, and delivered the Democratic response to Trump’s State of the Union address in March 2025. Her brand is that of a moderate, not a firebrand — which is precisely why her position carries weight. The revolt against Schumer is no longer confined to the party’s progressive wing.

At the news conference, Slotkin said whoever wants her vote must show “a concrete plan that’s definitively different” for using the new majority. “I’m a no until and unless I see that from anyone,” she said. She made clear she is not seeking the leadership job herself. Her stance hardened a position she first took on Saturday, when she told a Washington political conference audience that she would not rule out challenging Schumer herself. “I’m not ruling anything out,” she said then. That made her the first sitting Democratic senator to publicly leave open a challenge to Schumer. Three days later, she was standing next to Sanders, turning a solo signal into a joint statement.

The holdouts are growing

Sanders and Slotkin are not acting alone. Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York declined to back Schumer earlier on Tuesday, and Senator Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut declined to endorse him on Monday. A running tally of public positions counted four Senate Democrats who say they will not back Schumer, five more who want new leadership, 14 who have not committed, and only eight who say they will back him. Twenty-four senators have no public stance yet.

The pressure is strongest among the senators-elect who won on November 3. At least seven incoming Democratic senators have declined to commit to supporting Schumer, and several have gone further, saying outright that they will vote against him: Juliana Stratton of Illinois, Adam Hamilton of Kansas, Troy Jackson of Maine, Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan, Peggy Flanagan of Minnesota, Chris Pappas of New Hampshire and James Talarico of Texas. El-Sayed, the first Muslim elected to the United States Senate, has publicly backed Van Hollen as a possible alternative. Senator-elect Annie Andrews of South Carolina put the generational argument plainly: “I think it’s really clear that both parties are ready for a new generation of leadership.”

Van Hollen and the search for a challenger

For all the public discontent, no challenger has formally stepped forward yet. That is the strange shape of this revolt: broad opposition, no declared candidate, and a leader who insists the outcome is already settled.

Van Hollen is the name mentioned most often. The Maryland senator is being considered as a potential challenger and is open to a run, according to a person familiar with his thinking. When reporters asked Sanders who should lead instead, he pointed to Van Hollen. But when reporters asked Van Hollen himself on Tuesday whether he would challenge Schumer, he demurred, and he has said previously that running for leader is “not my focus” as he considers a presidential run in 2028.

The arithmetic is what makes Schumer vulnerable. Democrats will hold at least 54 Senate seats when the 120th Congress convenes in January, with races in Alaska and Mississippi still unresolved. Schumer needs only a simple majority of the caucus — roughly 29 votes — to keep the job. On paper, that should be comfortable. In practice, with seven incoming senators opposed or uncommitted and more established names now joining them, he has almost no margin for error.

Why Schumer is vulnerable — and what he says in his defence

The revolt has been building for months. A Gallup poll in December 2025 found that only 39 percent of Democrats approved of the job Schumer was doing, down from 76 percent two years earlier. Many in the party believe his cautious, institutional style now looks like a liability in a moment that demands confrontation. Schumer turns 76 later this month, and the senators-elect who won on November 3 are younger, more diverse and more willing to fight in public than the leadership that has run the party for a decade.

Schumer answered the challenge on Tuesday at his own news conference, appearing alongside Senators Kirsten Gillibrand, Sheldon Whitehouse and Ruben Gallego. “I’m confident I will be elected majority leader, and our caucus is really united in focusing on bringing down costs, on ending the corruption, on ending the chaos, on ending the war,” he said. “We have great unity in our caucus, and I’ll be proud to lead it as majority leader.”

His case rests on results: he led Senate Democrats through the 2026 campaign that delivered the majority, and his allies argue its architect deserves to lead it. Whitehouse said Schumer’s ability to deliver a Democratic Senate “certainly justifies another term as leader,” and Booker and Gallego have also spoken in his support. The counterargument, made openly by Sanders on Tuesday, is that winning the majority and leading it are two different jobs. The voters who delivered the Senate, Sanders argued, did not just hand Democrats power. They handed them a demand for change.

The US Capitol dome with the American flag in Washington, DC
The US Capitol dome with the American flag in Washington, DC. Photo by Pexels

How the vote will work

Senate Democrats will choose their leader by secret ballot in early December, before the new Congress is sworn in on January 3, 2027. The vote is held behind closed doors, which means senators can break with Schumer without facing an immediate public backlash — a format that has historically favoured challengers and made incumbents nervous. The House will hold its own leadership elections earlier, on November 18 and 19, and House Republicans chose Jim Jordan as their new leader on Tuesday, after losing more than 40 seats in the midterms.

The stakes go far beyond personalities. Whoever leads Senate Democrats will decide how the party uses its new majority in the final two years of Trump’s presidency — whether Democrats use it to investigate the administration and force votes on the cost of living, health care, tariffs and the war in Iran, or seek deals with a president who has shown little interest in compromise. Trump has already signalled his approach: on Friday, November 6, he named Stephen Miller, the architect of his hardline immigration agenda, as his new White House chief of staff.

What happens next

The next few weeks will decide whether this revolt produces a real contest or fizzles out. Between now and the December vote, Schumer must convince a caucus that includes at least seven sceptics that he has a plan for wielding the majority. Slotkin must decide whether her “not ruling anything out” becomes a campaign, and Van Hollen must decide whether to step forward. If no challenger emerges, Schumer will likely survive, wounded but in place. If one does, the party will face its first genuinely contested leadership election in years.

Leave a Comment