NEW YORK — New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani on Friday unveiled the city’s first comprehensive plan to close Rikers Island, the notorious jail complex in the East River, by 2032 — five years after the legal deadline — and replace it with four smaller borough-based jails, hundreds of new therapeutic beds and $146 million in mental health care, education and support for victims.
The 75-page “Close Rikers: Strategic Plan” is the most detailed roadmap the city has ever produced for shutting down the jail — and an admission that New York will miss the deadline the City Council set in 2019, when it ordered Rikers closed by August 2027.
“It is time to finally close Rikers Island,” Mamdani said at a City Hall news conference on Friday. “For decades, New Yorkers have demanded a correctional system that is safe and humane. This plan puts us on a path to deliver just that: closing Rikers, reducing pretrial detention, tackling the case delays that deprive people of their right to a speedy trial and investing $146 million in the evidence-based supports that help break the cycles of incarceration.”
What the Mamdani plan to close Rikers Island actually promises
At the heart of the plan are four borough-based jails, each designed to hold about 1,040 people, for a total of roughly 4,100 beds. The first, in downtown Brooklyn, is scheduled to open in 2029. Facilities in Queens and the Bronx would follow in 2031, and the Manhattan jail would open in 2032, the year Rikers itself is supposed to close for good.
The smaller jails are meant to sit close to courthouses, public transportation and the communities where incarcerated New Yorkers live, making it easier for people in custody to see family, make court dates and meet with lawyers. City Hall argues that the current setup — a remote island complex near LaGuardia Airport, reachable only by a single bridge — cuts people off from exactly the connections that help them return home and stay out of jail.
Alongside the new jails, the plan creates hundreds of therapeutic beds for people with serious mental health conditions and complex medical needs. The administration will add 236 Outposted Therapeutic Housing Units in Brooklyn and the Bronx, bringing the total to 340 therapeutic beds in NYC Health + Hospitals facilities across the city, on top of 106 such beds it says it has already opened.
Mamdani announced the plan alongside Department of Correction Commissioner Stanley Richards, the first formerly incarcerated person to lead the department, before taking questions at City Hall — arriving on crutches after a soccer injury, according to the New York Post. The plan was developed in consultation with the court-appointed remediation manager overseeing conditions at Rikers, and it builds on the closure framework drawn up under former Mayor Bill de Blasio, who first proposed replacing Rikers with four borough-based jails.

Why 2027 became 2032
The five-year delay is the most contentious part of the plan, and Mamdani did not try to hide it. The city is legally required to close Rikers by August 2027 under legislation the City Council passed in 2019, and the mayor acknowledged on Friday that the deadline will not be met.
His administration blames a combination of construction delays, the Covid-19 pandemic and what it calls the de-prioritization of the closure effort under his predecessor, former Mayor Eric Adams. The borough jails were already far behind schedule when Mamdani took office, and the first is not expected to open until 2029.
The delay also carries a steep price. The four-jail project has climbed from about $8.7 billion when it was first costed to roughly $16 billion, Mamdani said on Friday, according to Reuters.
Cutting the jail population from 6,600 to 4,100
The plan only works if New York can shrink its jail population dramatically. Rikers currently holds about 6,600 people. The four borough jails, between them, will hold only about 4,100. Closing the gap is the central challenge of the whole strategy.
Mamdani’s plan calls for the population to fall to 5,500 by the time the Brooklyn jail opens in 2029, and to no more than 4,100 people — including no more than 220 women — by the end of 2032. To get there, the administration is proposing more diversion programs, expanded supervised release and electronic monitoring, more housing and social services to prevent reoffending, and faster movement through the courts so people spend less time waiting for trial.
The administration will also invest $146 million in the next fiscal year in mental health care, substance-use treatment, educational and vocational programming inside jails and in communities, as well as services for victims of crime — aimed at the drivers of repeat incarceration, from untreated mental illness and addiction to the long waits in pretrial detention that can cost people jobs and housing before they have been convicted of anything.
What the City Council must do next
The plan cannot take effect on the mayor’s say-so alone. The City Council will introduce legislation to update the legal timeline for ending incarceration on Rikers Island, bringing the law into line with the construction schedule.
That sets up a fresh round of negotiations between the mayor and the Council, which passed the original 2019 closure law and has the power to extend the deadline — or to refuse. Council members who championed the 2019 law have spent years pressing the city to meet it, and some are likely to ask why five more years are needed and what guarantees the new date will hold. Whether the Council accepts the mayor’s construction-tied timetable will be one of the first big tests of his relationship with the legislature.

The opposition: the union, the neighbours and the cost
The plan is also expected to face opposition from two familiar quarters. The union representing correction officers has consistently pushed to keep Rikers open, arguing that the island complex is safer for staff and that the borough jails will be harder to run. Local communities near the planned borough jails have objected to hosting them.
The $16 billion price tag gives critics a third line of attack. At a moment when the city faces competing demands for housing, schools and transit, opponents will ask whether the money could be better spent elsewhere — and whether the project can be delivered on time and on budget after years of delays and rising costs.
Mamdani’s allies counter that Rikers itself is the expensive failure: a jail complex that has faced years of criticism over violence, deteriorating conditions and failures in caring for people with serious mental health and medical needs.
The mayor has moved quickly on criminal justice reform since taking office: just days earlier, he disbanded the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group, the controversial tactical unit that policed the city’s protests. The Rikers plan is the second major piece of that agenda, and it puts the new mayor’s name on the most ambitious jail reform in the city’s history.
Rikers’ long history — and why this time might be different
The campaign to close Rikers dates back to 1979, when reformers first argued that the island jail made rehabilitation almost impossible. For decades, the idea went nowhere: Rikers survived scandal after scandal, federal investigations and court orders.
The 2019 law was supposed to change that. It ordered the jail closed by 2027 and its population moved to four smaller facilities. But the plan stalled almost immediately: construction lagged, costs rose, neighbourhood opposition slowed the borough jails, and the pandemic disrupted both building and the courts.
Mamdani’s plan is the first to confront that history head-on, with a timetable that acknowledges the missed deadline rather than pretending it can still be met. Its supporters say that honesty is its strength. Its critics say a five-year delay is a broken promise by another name, and that the 2032 date will slip just as 2027 did — a failure that would be watched by reformers and law-enforcement groups across the country, since Rikers is one of the most notorious jail complexes in the United States.
What happens next
The immediate next step is the City Council, which must decide whether to pass legislation extending the closure deadline to 2032. The Mamdani plan to close Rikers Island will also need to keep the construction program on schedule, drive the jail population down by roughly 2,500 people over five years, and deliver the $146 million in services it has promised. The plan also lands as a new class of Black Democrats heading to Congress prepares to take its seats in January, shifting the national conversation on criminal justice reform.
For now, the plan gives New York a new date to aim for — and a new argument to have. The mayor who campaigned on closing Rikers has put his name on a detailed plan to do it, and whether the city can deliver it by 2032 will depend on the Council, the courts, the construction crews and the politics of a project that has already defeated two mayors.
Mamdani’s closing message on Friday was aimed at New Yorkers who have waited decades. “Our administration is determined to meet our moral and legal obligation to close Rikers Island once and for all,” he said. The plan is now public, the timetable is set, and the countdown to 2032 has begun.
(This is a developing story.)
