Mamdani Disbands NYPD Strategic Response Group in Sweeping Protest Policing Reform

NEW YORK — New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani on Monday disbanded the New York Police Department’s Strategic Response Group, the controversial tactical unit that has policed the city’s protests for more than a decade, fulfilling one of the central promises of his campaign for mayor.

Mamdani announced the move jointly with NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch, saying the city would separate protest policing from counterterrorism once and for all. The Strategic Response Group, known as the SRG, will no longer respond to demonstrations. Its counterterrorism duties will move to a different command, and a new civilian-led team will take the lead at protests.

“During our campaign, I promised New Yorkers that we would disband the Strategic Response Group and separate counterterrorism from protest response, and today we are delivering on that promise,” Mamdani said in a video announcing the changes. “New Yorkers exercising their constitutional right to protest should not be met with the same police response as a terrorism threat.”

What replaces the Strategic Response Group

Under the plan, protest response will be handled by two new units working together, one civilian and one inside the police department.

The Mayor’s Office of Community Safety will establish a Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division, a civilian-led team that will not carry weapons and will not have powers of arrest. Its job will be to talk with protest organisers, defuse tensions and coordinate the city’s response. It will work alongside the NYPD’s Community Affairs Bureau.

Inside the police department, a new 30-officer First Amendment Support Team will be trained in communication and de-escalation and will prepare for and respond to protests. A separate Patrol Support Division, staffed with vetted officers inside the Patrol Services Bureau, will focus on patrol-related duties and support protest responses where needed.

The new units will still make arrests at protests in rare instances if necessary, City Hall said — but arrests will no longer be the job of a tactical unit built for counterterrorism.

The SRG’s counterterrorism functions, including the deployment of heavily armed officers to protect critical infrastructure and major events, will be consolidated within the NYPD’s Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau. The unit itself will formally cease to exist as a standalone command, with the dissolution expected to be completed in spring 2027.

The tactics now banned

The reform also bans some of the most criticised tactics the SRG used at demonstrations.

Officers will be formally barred from kettling, the tactic in which police surround protesters and restrict them to a small area so mass arrests can be made. Tear gas and long guns will be prohibited at protests. Pepper spray will no longer be used as a crowd-management tool. Officers will also be barred from using bicycles as weapons against demonstrators, except in some extreme circumstances.

The bans answer years of complaints from protesters and civil liberties groups, who say the SRG’s tactics turned peaceful demonstrations into confrontations. They also go further than the limits the department agreed to in earlier legal settlements.

The New York City skyline
The New York City skyline. Photo by Malcolm Hill / Pexels.

What the Strategic Response Group was

The Strategic Response Group was created in 2015 with a focus on counterterrorism. It was designed as a rapid-response force that could deploy heavily armed officers to terrorist threats, major emergencies and large public events.

But over time, its mission expanded. The roughly 500-officer unit became the department’s go-to force for policing protests, frequently deployed to demonstrations with riot gear, long guns and armoured vehicles. Critics say that dual role — counterterrorism and protest policing in the same unit — was the problem from the start.

The fiercest criticism came after the 2020 Black Lives Matter demonstrations in New York. The city’s Department of Investigation later found that the NYPD had used excessive force against protesters in violation of their First Amendment rights, and said the SRG had played a “central role” in policing those protests. The report recommended that officials re-evaluate the unit’s role at demonstrations.

The controversy did not fade. The unit drew a high number of complaints, lawsuits and expensive legal settlements. On the campaign trail, Mamdani said the SRG had “cost taxpayers millions in lawsuit settlements [and] brutalized countless New Yorkers exercising their First Amendment rights.”

The unit remained a flashpoint this year. Calls to disband it intensified after clashes between officers and protesters demonstrating against the federal government’s immigration enforcement, including protests this fall over a shooting in the Bronx during a U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement operation. The SRG had also been deployed at anti-Israel demonstrations across the city.

Yet by the department’s own figures, the unit was rarely at protests. The NYPD facilitated 4,255 protests during 2025, and the SRG was present at 245 of them — about 6 percent. It has responded to fewer than 20 demonstrations in 2026 and made about a dozen arrests. Supporters say those numbers show it was used sparingly and only when needed. Critics say they show a heavily armed unit was kept in reserve for the wrong job.

Why Mamdani acted now

Mamdani, a democratic socialist who took office in January, campaigned on dismantling the SRG and moving some police responsibilities to a new department of community safety. He repeated the promise at a press conference in September, arguing that the unit’s original counterterrorism mission had expanded into an inappropriate combination of security operations and protest enforcement.

But the announcement on Monday followed months of mounting criticism from some of his most left-leaning supporters, who said he had not done enough to reform public safety or the NYPD since taking office. The reforms, the Mamdani administration said, have been under development since January — and the mayor’s team chose to move now, as pressure from his progressive allies reached its peak.

The plan mirrors a legislative proposal by New York City Council member Chi Ossé, known as the CURB Act, which would prohibit the SRG from responding to protests and limit police tactics at demonstrations. Mamdani has endorsed the bill. “These reforms accomplish the key changes called for by Councilmember Ossé’s CURB Act, a bill I am proud to support,” he said.

Notably, the changes have the backing of Commissioner Tisch, whom Mamdani retained from the previous administration. Tisch has presided over a dramatic drop in crime during her nearly two years in the role, and she told officers on Monday morning that the department would retain its ability to confront serious threats while adopting a different approach to public demonstrations. Her support gives the reform credibility with the department’s rank and file that a mayoral order alone might not have carried.

The timing also fits a wider political moment. Across the country, the Democrats who take control of Congress in January are preparing to challenge the Trump administration, and in New York the mayor’s move is being read as part of the same shift — a Democratic Party that won power on promises of change and is now being pressed to deliver it.

Reaction: praise from supporters, warnings from police unions

Reaction to the announcement split along familiar lines. Civil liberties advocates and progressive lawmakers welcomed the move as a long-overdue correction. For them, the SRG had become a symbol of the militarisation of protest policing, and its disbanding is proof that a mayor can keep a campaign promise on policing.

Police unions took the opposite view. They warned that disbanding the unit will endanger New Yorkers and create chaos, disrupting daily life and enabling demonstrators to escalate their tactics and block bridges or roadways. Supporters of the SRG say its specialised training makes it the best-equipped force to handle demonstrations that turn violent — and that removing it leaves a gap no de-escalation team can fill.

That argument will be tested at the next major protest. If demonstrations stay peaceful under the new system, the mayor will claim vindication. If one turns violent and the new units struggle, the unions’ warning will be quoted back at him.

The debate also turns on framing. Mamdani calls the move a disbanding. Others note that the SRG’s counterterrorism officers and heavy weapons are not disappearing — they are being consolidated into another bureau. The unit is being eliminated as a standalone command, but the capability it represented is being reorganised rather than abolished.

The New York City skyline and the Brooklyn Bridge at night
The New York City skyline and the Brooklyn Bridge at night. Photo by Pixabay / Pexels.

What happens next

The formal dissolution of the SRG is expected in spring 2027, and the civilian protest-response programme will be developed over the coming year. In the meantime, the new units will take over protest duties, and the Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau will absorb the SRG’s counterterrorism work.

The change also comes as Washington’s lame-duck session grinds on, with Congress facing a December 11 government funding deadline and Democrats preparing to take control in January.

For now, Mamdani has done what he promised voters he would do. The unit he campaigned against is being disbanded, the tactics he condemned are being banned, and a civilian-led approach to protest is taking its place. What happens on New York’s streets next will decide whether that promise was wise — or merely popular.

Leave a Comment